Paper mailers: flat vs padded, sizes and cost: ProntoPack packaging guide

Paper Mailers: Flat vs. Padded, Sizes, and What They Cost by the Case

Key takeaways

  • Paper mailers come flat (a self-seal paper pouch) or padded (a honeycomb paper layer inside).
  • By the case: flat Curb Pouch $0.09–$0.28 per mailer; padded HexCoat $0.40–$1.10.
  • At 9×12, a flat paper mailer costs $0.110 vs $0.057 for a 2.0 mil poly mailer; brands pick paper for plastic-free packaging, not price.

A paper mailer is a self-seal shipping envelope made of paper instead of plastic film, and it comes in two kinds: a flat paper pouch for soft goods and a padded paper mailer for items that need cushioning. On the ProntoPack store, flat Curb Pouch paper mailers run $0.09 to $0.28 each by the case (7×10 to 19×24 in), and padded HexCoat honeycomb paper mailers run $0.40 to $1.10 each (6.5×10 to 14.25×20 in).

Comparison of flat Curb Pouch paper mailers at $0.09 to $0.28 each and padded HexCoat honeycomb paper mailers at $0.40 to $1.10 each, with paper vs poly cost at 9 by 12 inches
Flat Curb Pouch paper mailers at $0.09 to $0.28 each and padded HexCoat honeycomb paper mailers at $0.40 to $1.10 each, with paper vs poly cost at 9 by 12 inches

What is the difference between a flat and a padded paper mailer?

A flat paper mailer is a single paper pouch with a peel-off self-seal strip. It does the job of a poly mailer for apparel, books and other non-fragile goods, and it is very light, which keeps postage down. A padded paper mailer adds cushioning. Our HexCoat mailers use a 3-layer paper build with a honeycomb paper layer inside, so they protect against bumps the way a bubble mailer does, without a plastic layer.

Both formats close tape-free and are listed on the store as curbside recyclable. They come from our U.S. manufacturing partners and ship from U.S. inventory.

What do paper mailers cost by the case?

Store case prices for paper mailers:

Mailer Size Case Case price Per mailer
Curb Pouch (flat) 7 × 10 in 1,000 $89.99 $0.090
Curb Pouch (flat) 9 × 12 in 500 $54.99 $0.110
Curb Pouch (flat) 12 × 15 in 500 $69.99 $0.140
Curb Pouch (flat) 14 × 19 in 200 $39.99 $0.200
Curb Pouch (flat) 19 × 24 in 200 $54.99 $0.275
HexCoat (padded) 6.5 × 10 in 250 $99.99 $0.400
HexCoat (padded) 8.5 × 12 in 100 $54.99 $0.550
HexCoat (padded) 10.5 × 16 in 100 $74.99 $0.750
HexCoat (padded) 14.25 × 20 in 50 $54.99 $1.100

Pallet and truckload tiers are on the wholesale line sheet.

Which paper mailer size do I need?

Measure the item flat, then add about 2 inches to the width and 3 inches to the length so the seal closes over its thickness. A 9×12 flat mailer suits a folded T-shirt or a paperback; 12×15 takes a hoodie or two or three folded garments; 14×19 and 19×24 cover bulky knits, jackets and bundles. For padded mailers, size to the item plus its thickness, since the honeycomb layer takes up some of the inside.

Paper mailer vs. poly mailer: which costs less?

Poly costs less per mailer. At 9×12, a flat paper mailer is $0.110 against $0.057 for a 2.0 mil poly mailer; at 12×15, paper is $0.140 against $0.096 for a 12×15.5 poly mailer. Poly also resists water and tearing better, which matters for rain, wet loading docks and rough sorting.

Paper wins when the brand is paper-forward and customers expect plastic-free packaging, or when you want a mailer the customer can put in the paper bin. Many brands use both: poly for everyday apparel orders and paper for a plastic-free line or a subscription box. The poly vs. bubble vs. paper comparison has the full decision tree.

Padded paper mailer vs. bubble mailer

A bubble mailer costs less, and a padded paper mailer drops the plastic. At 8.5×12, a HexCoat padded paper mailer is $0.55 against $0.36 for a #2 kraft bubble mailer and $0.33 for a white poly bubble mailer. Choose padded paper for cosmetics, accessories and small boxed goods when plastic-free matters to the brand; choose bubble when cost per order is the priority.

»
Test before you switch: the $29 sample kit includes paper, poly and bubble mailers, and the $29 is credited against your first wholesale order.

FAQ

How much do paper mailers cost? On the ProntoPack store, flat Curb Pouch paper mailers cost $0.090 (7×10, 1,000 per case) to $0.275 (19×24, 200 per case) each, and padded HexCoat honeycomb mailers cost $0.40 (6.5×10) to $1.10 (14.25×20) each.

Are paper mailers cheaper than poly mailers? No. Poly mailers cost less: at 9×12 a 2.0 mil poly mailer is $0.057 against $0.110 for a flat paper mailer. Brands choose paper for plastic-free packaging, not for price.

Are paper mailers waterproof? No. Paper resists light handling moisture but is not water-resistant like polyethylene film. If parcels sit out in rain or on wet docks, a poly mailer protects the contents better.

Can paper mailers protect fragile items? Padded ones can. HexCoat mailers have a honeycomb paper layer that cushions bumps; flat paper pouches are for soft, non-fragile goods like apparel and books.

Buying at volume?

Our wholesale line sheet publishes per-unit pricing by pallet tier — no quote request needed to see numbers. Want to touch the product first? The $29 sample kit covers six product lines and is credited in full against your first wholesale order.

See the line sheetOrder the $29 sample kit

Questions? Call (619) 703-0245 — we manufacture our poly & bubble mailers in Tijuana and ship from U.S. inventory.

Regresar al blog